openai-whisper-vs-other-open-source-transcription-models

What is the best model for automatic transcription? OpenAI Whisper stands out for its accuracy and multilingual support, but it is not the only option. Other models like Vosk, Kaldi, and Coqui STT offer open-source alternatives with various advantages, such as lower resource consumption or greater customization.

Quick summary:

  • Whisper: High accuracy (reduces errors by 50%), supports 99 languages, and allows direct translation to English. Ideal for companies with multilingual needs, although it requires powerful hardware.

  • Vosk: Lightweight and efficient, with 50 MB models for devices with limited resources. Compatible with over 20 languages.

  • Kaldi: Highly customizable but complex to install and use. Recommended for technical experts.

  • Coqui STT: Based on DeepSpeech, with a community focus and multilingual support, although in maintenance mode.

Quick comparison:

Model

Accuracy

Supported languages

Technical requirements

Key advantages

Whisper

Very high (99 languages)

99

Recommended GPU

Integrated multilingual translation

Vosk

Medium

20+

Low

Lightweight, ideal for mobile

Kaldi

High (tunable)

Variable (customizable)

High

Full customization

Coqui STT

Medium-high

Multilingual

Medium

Community philosophy

Conclusion: Whisper offers the best accuracy in multiple languages, but models like Vosk or Kaldi may be more suitable for companies with limited resources or specific needs. The choice depends on factors like language, budget, and technical experience.

Features and capabilities of OpenAI Whisper

OpenAI Whisper

Technical design and language support

OpenAI Whisper is based on an encoder-decoder transformer architecture, designed to efficiently process audio. The model converts audio to a frequency of 16,000 Hz and transforms it into an 80-channel Mel spectrogram, using 25 ms windows and a 10 ms step.

This structure enables it to provide robust multilingual support. Whisper has been trained with 680,000 hours of multilingual data collected from the web, of which approximately 117,000 hours correspond to 96 languages other than English. This means that one-third of its dataset is not in English, reinforcing its ability to handle multiple languages effectively.

"Whisper is an automatic speech recognition (ASR) system trained on 680,000 hours of multilingual and multitask supervised data collected from the web. We show that the use of such a large and diverse dataset leads to improved robustness to accents, background noise, and technical language. Moreover, it enables transcription in multiple languages, as well as translation from those languages into English."

Currently, Whisper officially supports 99 languages, including Spanish and other European languages. However, it is worth mentioning that 65% of the training data focused on English, while only 17% was dedicated to multilingual tasks. This could influence accuracy when working with languages less represented in the training.

Transcription accuracy and main features

Accuracy is one of Whisper's strengths. According to OpenAI, the model reduces errors by 50% compared to other similar systems when evaluated across various datasets. This advancement is due to the use of diverse data in its training, which enhances its ability to recognize accents, manage background noise, and understand technical terms.

Whisper also stands out by including special tokens that expand its functionalities. Here are some of its key capabilities:

  • Automatic language identification: automatically detects the language of the audio.

  • Precise timestamps: generates timestamps at the phrase level, facilitating synchronization with multimedia content.

  • Integrated translation: enables direct translation from various languages to English.

"As explained by OpenAI, the text captions are then intermixed with special tokens that direct the single model to perform tasks such as language identification, phrase-level timestamps, multilingual speech transcription, and to-English speech translation."

Installation and integration options

Whisper not only stands out for its technical design but also for its ease of integration. To install it, you need to have Python, pip, and ffmpeg, tools necessary for processing audio.

The model can be used in two ways: via the command line for specific tasks or integrated into Python scripts to automate more complex processes. To maximize its performance, it is recommended to have sufficient RAM, a powerful CPU, and, if possible, to take advantage of GPU support, which significantly reduces processing times.

Local installation offers significant advantages, especially in professional environments. It provides full control over the data, eliminates dependence on external APIs, and reduces long-term costs. Additionally, Whisper supports a variety of audio formats and operates reliably even in challenging conditions, though it achieves better results with clear audio. These features make it a practical tool for various applications, improving productivity in professional settings.

Open AI Whisper - Open Source Translation and Transcription

Other open-source transcription models

In addition to Whisper, there are other open-source options that offer different combinations of efficiency, customization, and technical requirements.

Vosk: lightweight and efficient transcription

Vosk

Vosk is a practical option for offline transcriptions, especially on devices with limited resources. This speech recognition toolkit stands out for its efficiency and ease of use.

One of its main advantages is the small size of its models: compact models per language occupy only 50 MB each. It also has larger models for servers, designed for applications that demand higher precision. This makes it an ideal solution for devices with little storage space or mobile applications.

To install Vosk, simply run pip3 install vosk. Additionally, it supports over 20 languages, including Spanish, and offers advanced features like speaker identification, a streaming API for real-time transcription, and the ability to adjust the vocabulary to improve accuracy in specific terminology. It also includes bindings for programming languages like Java, C#, and JavaScript.

Another strong point is processing speed, as its models are considerably faster than Whisper's. However, for those seeking complete control, Kaldi can be an alternative, although with increased complexity.

Kaldi: customization for experts

Kaldi

Kaldi is a powerful and highly customizable framework that allows tuning almost every aspect of the speech recognition process. From acoustic models to decoding algorithms, it is an ideal tool for researchers and companies that need detailed control.

However, this flexibility comes at a cost. Installing Kaldi can take several hours and requires about 40 GB of disk space. Additionally, its use demands advanced technical knowledge and a considerable learning curve. Despite these difficulties, it has an active community and extensive documentation. Against this complexity, Coqui STT emerges as another interesting alternative within the open-source ecosystem.

Coqui STT: community focus

Coqui STT

Coqui STT, the successor to Mozilla DeepSpeech, is based on a community development philosophy. This project seeks to enhance multilingual support and offer faster inference, making it appealing for community-driven initiatives.

An example of its application is the voice plugin for WebThings.IO, where Coqui STT acts as an interface for voice-controlled applications. However, the project is currently in maintenance mode, with limited updates and declining community support. Its main advantage is the ability to implement voice control technologies that operate locally, which is ideal for environments where privacy is paramount.

Each of these alternatives has specific features that will later be directly compared with Whisper to help companies make a decision based on their specific needs.

Direct comparison: OpenAI Whisper vs other models

In the open-source ecosystem, there are various solutions with features that make them unique. Here, we analyze the most relevant aspects for Spanish companies looking to implement transcription tools, allowing evaluation of which model best fits their needs.

Accuracy and performance in languages

When we talk about accuracy, Whisper excels at reducing errors by 50% in zero-shot contexts. This makes it a standout option, especially in multilingual environments. Whisper not only transcribes in 99 languages but also offers translation to English.

In the case of Spanish, all the analyzed models offer support, although with different levels of accuracy. Whisper stands out for its versatility in multiple languages, which is essential for companies with international reach. On the other hand, Vosk supports over 20 languages and dialects, including Spanish. Kaldi, known for its reliable code, uses traditional models like HMMs and GMMs, differentiating itself from Whisper's deep learning techniques. Coqui STT, the successor of DeepSpeech, offers models trained with high-quality data and multilingual support, while DeepSpeech achieves a word error rate (WER) of 7.5%.

"AI-transcription accuracy is now decidedly superior to the average human's, what the implications of this are I'm not sure." - pen2l, Hacker News Commenter

Setup and integration

The ease of setup varies among models. Whisper comes with a relatively simple installation, although it requires powerful hardware. According to OpenAI:

"We hope Whisper's high accuracy and ease of use will allow developers to add voice interfaces to a much wider set of applications"

This approach combines accuracy with ease of use, although the hardware requirements may pose a challenge for some companies.

Real-time performance and system requirements

Real-time performance is another key point. Whisper is faster on NVIDIA CUDA-enabled GPU equipment, although it can also run on systems without this capability, albeit at lower speeds. Regarding requirements, Whisper large-v3 needs around 10 GB of VRAM, while Whisper turbo requires approximately 6 GB.

On the other hand, Faster-Whisper offers a significant improvement, reaching speeds up to 380 times greater on long files.

These technical aspects are crucial for companies with high volumes of audio. Ghislaine G., from Madrid, shared her experience:

"The level of accuracy and your UI is quite amazing. It allowed me to try the product without having to learn anything new; I was so happy about it I sent the results to a couple of friends because I knew at the moment that this could change the way I work."

The choice of model will depend on factors like audio volume, available resources, and accuracy demands, all of which are decisive for Spanish companies.

Using transcription models to improve productivity

Current transcription models have transformed the way companies manage tasks, allowing them to automate processes that previously required hours of manual work. This not only saves time but also frees up resources for teams to focus on more strategic activities.

Automation of meeting and interview documentation

Documenting meetings manually can be a tedious process and consume valuable hours of work. This is where transcription models make a difference: they automate the creation of structured summaries, identify key elements, and facilitate searches in large volumes of multimedia data.

The audio quality and language specification are key factors for obtaining more accurate results [37,38]. Additionally, these tools allow for customizing outputs by adding timestamping and confidence scores that enhance the content's usefulness [37,38].

These models not only optimize business management but also integrate with assistive technologies, helping people with speech difficulties or those who rely on written communication. In customer service, these tools have proven useful in improving response times and accuracy in handling inquiries, resulting in a better customer experience.

Jamy.ai: productivity tools driven by transcription

Jamy.ai

A standout example of this technology is Jamy.ai, a platform that utilizes transcription models to enhance business efficiency. Among its features, Jamy.ai automatically detects tasks, allows for easy language switching, and offers customizable templates for managing meetings.

Alexia Lafitau, CEO of Odys.travel, comments on the platform's effectiveness:

"I love that Jamy automatically assigns tasks to the people who need to carry them out. I no longer have to create tasks manually, which saves a lot of time."

On the other hand, Chris Chaput, COO of Cadana, highlights the impact on reporting:

"Jamy.ai has been a game changer for my customer success team. It allows them to automatically send meeting reports to clients."

With support for over 50 languages, the platform integrates with CRM systems and collaboration tools, allowing businesses to maintain their usual workflows while adding advanced transcription capabilities.

Spanish support for international teams

Multilingual support is becoming increasingly important for companies operating in multiple countries. According to a survey by HR Brew, 54% of companies operate in two or more countries. In the United States, approximately 20% of people speak a language other than English at home.

In the case of Iberian Spanish, the accuracy levels vary by model. For example, Sonix Engine achieves a 98.7% accuracy, exceeding the industry average of 97.1%. Maestra ASR, under ideal conditions, reports a word error rate (WER) of 8.2%, while OpenAI Whisper has a WER of 14.7%.

The impact of these technologies is reflected in specific cases. In 2023, MediaPro Barcelona reduced post-production time by 40% when subtitling documentaries in Catalan and Basque using Sonix Engine. Meanwhile, the Generalitat Valenciana managed to decrease the time needed to document plenary sessions by 40% thanks to Maestra ASR.

Regarding costs, options vary considerably. OpenAI Whisper charges €0.0055/minute, while Sonix Engine offers plans starting at €15/month for 100 minutes. Maestra ASR has a basic plan of €39/month, and Deepgram Nova charges €0.0072/minute.

The ability to perform multilingual transcriptions not only facilitates communication among international teams but also ensures that all members are aligned, regardless of the language they speak. For Spanish companies with global operations, this technology is key to maintaining cohesion and ensuring that critical information reaches all involved.

Choosing the right transcription model

When comparing different options, key criteria are identified to help select the most appropriate transcription model for each company. The decision largely depends on the specific needs of each organization.

Summary of comparison results

Whisper excels in accuracy (up to 90% under complicated conditions) and its ability to work with multiple languages, thanks to its training with 680,000 hours of data, of which one-third corresponds to languages other than English. This makes it a standout option for companies handling content in various languages.

In terms of usability, differences between models are notable. Whisper requires a high level of technical resources and allows for complete control over its implementation, operating locally to ensure data privacy. On the other hand, API solutions offer a fully managed infrastructure and advanced features, although their costs can increase significantly as they scale.

Aspect

Whisper (Open Source)

API Solutions

Initial cost

Free (no licenses)

Pay-as-you-go starting at €0.006/min

Infrastructure

Requires technical investment

Fully managed

Real-time

Not available

Yes available

Customization

High (total control of the deployment)

Limited

Scalability

Complex without additional investment

Easily scalable

With this information, it is possible to analyze the factors that Spanish companies should specifically consider.

Factors for Spanish companies

Spanish companies face specific challenges when choosing a transcription model. One key point is precision in Spanish, which can vary by provider. Therefore, it is essential to conduct tests with representative audio samples before making a decision.

A relevant aspect in Spain is support for regional accents. Whisper allows for adjusting the model to accommodate specific variations of the language, which is especially useful for handling different Spanish accents. This flexibility can make a significant difference in accuracy when working with local dialects.

In terms of operating costs, while Whisper has no licensing fees, it requires an initial investment in hardware and technical knowledge. In contrast, API solutions, like Google Speech-to-Text, are easier to integrate, although their prices are higher (for example, €0.016/minute compared to €0.006/minute for Whisper's API).

Another determining factor is the technical expertise available within the company. A cloud-based model, although less accurate, that can be implemented in a few days may be more practical than a more precise open-source model that requires months of work to operate reliably.

For multilingual teams, it is essential to carefully verify the languages that will be used. Claims of compatibility with "over 100 languages" do not always guarantee optimal performance in production. In this regard, Whisper stands out for offering high accuracy in a wide variety of languages in real-world scenarios.

Finally, for companies handling sensitive data, Whisper offers the possibility of local deployment, providing a higher level of privacy.

FAQs

What advantages does Whisper offer over other open-source transcription models?

What makes Whisper special?

Whisper stands out among other open-source models due to its great accuracy, even when acoustic conditions are challenging. Additionally, it is capable of transcribing audio in 99 languages, making it a practical tool for people around the world.

Another of its significant advantages is its ease of use and integration. This allows it to be quickly incorporated into various projects without the need for complex setups. Therefore, it is an attractive option for both professionals and companies seeking quick and easy-to-implement solutions.

What should I consider when choosing a transcription model for my company regarding accuracy and costs?

Evaluating transcription models: accuracy and costs

When choosing a transcription model, there are two factors you should consider: accuracy and costs.

In terms of accuracy, pay attention to the word error rate (WER), which indicates how exact the model is. It is also important to evaluate how it performs with different audio qualities or a variety of accents. On the cost side, review the price per hour of transcription and its capability to handle large volumes of data efficiently. This can be key to saving money in the long run.

Selecting a model that fits the specific needs of your business can make a significant difference in productivity and resource optimization.

How does Whisper's multilingual support influence its accuracy when transcribing less common languages?

Whisper's multilingual support

Whisper has the capability to transcribe in a wide range of languages, but its level of accuracy varies depending on the amount of data it has been trained on for each language. In languages with broader representation, the model usually delivers very accurate results. In contrast, in less common languages or those with fewer available data, accuracy may be affected.

Despite these limitations, Whisper stands out as an effective tool for multilingual transcriptions. It is particularly useful in scenarios where multiple languages are handled or when work needs to be done with different accents and dialects. This ability to adapt to multiple languages makes it a valuable resource in international or multicultural environments.

Related posts

Frequently Asked Questions

Frequently Asked Questions

Free trial plan for Jamy?
What are the pricing plans?
How does Jamy work?
How is my information protected?
Does Jamy integrate with other tools?

Jamy.ai

Jamy.ai is an AI-powered meeting assistant that joins your virtual calls, records audio and video, generates transcriptions, summaries, and extracts the main topics and tasks related to the meeting.

©2024 Copyrights Reserved by Jamy Technologies, LLC